Showing posts with label Industry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Industry. Show all posts

Monday, March 30, 2009

Documentary Review: The Union - The Business Behind Getting High

Today the MJO reviews The Union: The Business Behind Getting High, a Canadian documentary that is centered on British Columbia’s grow scene which is apparently called “The Union.” The documentary is expansive in scope and also examines a number of different facets of marijuana and its illegal industry. While we found The Union to be well-researched and very informative, in the end we found it’s kitchen-sink approach to marijuana issues to be overwhelming.

The Union begins with a brief history of marijuana and hemp use in the United States, discussing the beneficial uses of the two plants. It points out that the first marijuana law in America directed citizens to grow hemp. The Union examines marijuana’s path from favored crop to prohibited drug scourge in great detail.

Then there is an examination of prohibition and a lot of the arguments used by prohibitionists that do not stand up to closer scrutiny:
  1. Marijuana is toxic and can cause cancer. There is very little evidence to support this proposition.
  2. Marijuana is the most addictive drug. The documentary points out that scientists consider coffee to be more addictive than marijuana.
  3. Marijuana is a gateway drug. Again there is no evidence to support this. There is no inherent pharmacological property of marijuana that would predispose one to try cocaine or heroin.
  4. Marijuana makes you unproductive. Many business and political leaders have admitted to smoking marijuana.
  5. Marijuana leads to crime and violence. The documentary points out that the crime associated with marijuana is not committed by users but occurs as a result of marijuana prohibition and the ensuing criminals that this policy empowers. Alcohol leads to much more crime and violence today. Moreover, when alcohol was prohibited it led to the rise of organized crime and criminal figures such as Al Capone.
Perhaps the documentary’s best argument against prohibition is that drug dealers are for it because otherwise they would have no avenue to make the enormous profits that they are currently making of marijuana.

[As an aside, one of the more interesting prohibition stories revealed regards the Reagan administration’s shocking announcement that marijuana use inevitably leads to permanent brain damage. As support for his contention, President Reagan pointed to the Heath/Tulane study, in which monkeys were subjected to the equivalent of smoking thirty joints a day, for the period of one year. However, The Union makes the claim that rather than thirty joints a day, the monkeys were fitted with a gas mask and were pumped with what amounted to sixty-three Colombian strength joints in the span of approximately five minutes. The monkeys suffered from atrophy and inevitably suffered brain damage from lack of oxygen intake. The Reagan administration falsely claimed that their evidence was proof that marijuana was potentially the most dangerous drug ever.]

From there the documentary rapidly examines various marijuana issues including BC bud, Canadian “grow ops,” neighborhood “Grow Watches,” the union of marijuana growers and dealers, Cannabis day, Tommy Chong, Marc Emery, the jail construction industry, the rise of private prisons, the rise of the drug testing industry, Big Pharma’s opposition to marijuana legalization, Marinol, Hempfest, and the various uses of hemp. However, as a result of throwing the kitchen sink at the viewer, The Union loses sight of each topic and never really gains insightful focus in a significant and meaningful way. That is not to say that The Union is not a well made documentary. Far from it. However, one might wonder whether tackling such a huge topic and attempting to cram the large amount of information into a 104 minute documentary might have been a misstep. With such a large amount of content to explore, the film’s creators may have been better served with breaking The Union into a multi-part series.

Furthermore, the ending of The Union is somewhat disappointing. After what starts out as a very serious and factual documentary, the ending loses course and becomes somewhat preachy. As a result, the ending is anti-climactic and a let-down. In fact, the unusual choice to essentially end the documentary where it started is a bit of an Achilles heel for The Union, since the ending does not focus on marijuana but rather the hemp industry.

The majority of the people interviewed all have a huge connection to the marijuana culture. Scientists, doctors, growers, police officers, economists and politicians are shown discussing the marijuana trade, and for the most part give intelligent and considerate answers that are sure to raise some serious questions for the uninformed populace. However, the filmmakers made the unusual decision to also interview Joe Rogan, best known for his work as a UFC analyst and his stints on the television shows NewsRadio and Fear Factor. This decision was a bit odd considering the number of experts that were lined up to be interviewed for the documentary. Joe Rogan has no relation to the marijuana industry, and for all intents and purposes, is not a legitimate marijuana smoker. Mr. Rogan admits to having started smoking marijuana at the age of 30. And rather than interject with any sort of intelligent dialogue, Mr. Rogan sees fit to degrade the quality of the documentary by constantly cursing into the camera. The inclusion of Mr. Rogan was a poor choice, and gives a film that is aimed at being serious, intelligent, and informative an unwelcome juvenile touch.

A related weakness is that there are no people interviewed that are anti-marijuana legalization. Perhaps the makers of The Union felt that those arguments were passé and that they had dealt with them effectively throughout the documentary. However, the lack of interviewed counterpoints leaves The Union very open to accusations of bias.

In the end, the MJO recommends that you watch The Union. While it is not perfect and there is substantial room for improvement, it is still one of the best documentaries on the marijuana industry that we have ever seen.

The Union: The Business Behind Getting High
Executive Producer: Adam Scorgie
Director: Brett Harvey
Awards:
  1. 2008 Leo Awards: nominated for Best Overall Sound in a Documentary Program or Series
  2. 2008 Leo Awards: nominated for Best Sound Editing in a Documentary Program or Series
  3. 2007 Rhode Island International Film Festival: Won Best Editing (Stephen Green)
  4. 2007 Winnipeg International Film Festival: Won Outstanding Documentary Feature (Brett Harvey)
This post was written in conjunction with MJO cheif-of-staff Yellowcake.
Read More...

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Economics: The Stimulus, State Budget Deficits, and Marijuana.

Like many of you, the staff at MJO has been closely following the stimulus proceedings in Washington. While President Obama was able to use his mandate to push through a $787 billion spending plan in record-breaking time, several states were still facing the difficult propositions of budget deficits and, unlike the federal government, states are not allowed to go into the red to pay for their programs. After watching CNBC's Marijuana, Inc. and other documentaries about the marijuana industry (reviews coming soon!), we have been thoroughly convinced that marijuana is a multi-billion dollar business. Thus, we at the MJO were curious: 1) Would legalization and taxation of marijuana provide significant revenue to the states? and 2) Is the political climate ripe for such a drastic change in American marijuana public policy?

The issue of state budget shortfalls has become more acute this week with the state of California's maneuverings to remain solvent. California is facing a budget deficit of some $42 billion dollars, with a $11.2 billion revenue shortfall for this year alone. This Tuesday, in order to motivate California Senate Republicans to agree to the proposed Schwarzenegger/Democrat budget, Schwarzenegger sent out 10,000 layoff notices to state workers. In order to avoid the laying off of another 10,000 state workers (as promised by the Governator if no budget was agreed upon) state lawmakers finally passed California's 2009 state budget. California's problems may be more pronounced, but other states are also facing huge deficits.

When one considers that illegal marijuana sales
have been estimated to exceed $14 billion a year nationally, a figure larger than California's yearly budget shortfalls, one has to at least consider the possibility of taxing marijuana for fundraising purposes. But, of course, the entire $14 billion would not go to the states, so what kind of tax revenue are we really looking at? Luckily, Jefferey Miron, a Harvard economics professor, has done the calculations for us in his landmark paper, "The Budgetary Implications of Marijuana Prohibition." We recommend you read the entire report, but Miron's somewhat conservative conclusion is that marijuana legalization would yield tax revenue of $2.4 billion annually if marijuana was taxed like all other goods and $6.2 billion if marijuana was to be taxed at rates similar to alcohol or tobacco. But it doesn't stop there, Miron also estimates that legalizing marijuana would save $7.7 billion per year in government expenditure due to prohibition enforcement. $5.3 billion of this savings would accrue to state and local governments, while $2.4 billion would accrue to the federal government.

Making the safe assumption that marijuana would be subject to a sin tax like alcohol and cigarettes, that leads to a total governmental savings of $13.9 billion dollars. While this figure pales in comparison to recent government stimulus packages, it is still a quite a bit of money. Moreover, while no state would reap as much as California, every state would make at least some revenue. And before Morin is dismissed as a pothead or crackpot New England liberal, it must be noted that 500 prominent economists signed a letter agreeing to his findings including Nobel Laureates Vernon Smith, George Akerlof, and the godfather of free-market economics himself Milton Friedman.

This leads us to our second question, is the political climate right for such a drastic change in American drug policies? Recently, Zogby International released a poll commissioned by the California arm of the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws indicated that 58% of respondents from the west coast of the United States favored legalizing marijuana and taxing it like alcohol or cigarettes, while only 36% opposed the regulated sale of marijuana. This cannot be characterized as a purely west coast phenomena either, as a more mainstream poll commissioned by CBS and The New York Times revealed that 41% of Americans nationwide favored legalization, as opposed to 27% in 1979. It must be noted that the latter poll did not ask any questions about taxation or states revenue-raising, so responses may be more favorable in a subsequent poll incorporating either of these concepts.

Ultimately, even the best-case figure of 58% is probably not a high-enough percentage of people to change a marijuana narco-policy that has been well-established for years. With the populace trending younger and thus less prohibitionist, one day it may be politically possible to advocate marijuana legalization. However, with states facing ever-increasing budget deficits and calls to raise personal income taxes to meet them potentially forthcoming, perhaps we are approaching the time when calling for marijuana legalization and taxation becomes politically necessary and not just politically possible.


Read More...

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Television Review: CNBC's Marijuana, Inc.


Today MJO reviews CNBC's special report Marijuana, Inc.: Inside America's Pot Industry that first aired on January 22, 2009. We'll admit we came in with high expectations considering it was being offered by America's Business Channel. However, ultimately, we found it disappointing and believe it did not give the multi-billion dollar Marijuana Industry the proper treatment it deserves.

The beginning started solidly, covering the rise of the Marijuana trafficking industry in Mendocino County and featuring interviews with Eric Sligh the editor of the popular trade magazine Grow. They painted a picture of Mendocino as a county in which the marijuana industry was so prevalent that it was reliant upon marijuana growing and selling for its very economic survival. Scary figures were thrown about:
  1. Sixty percent of the county's populace was involved in the trade.
  2. The industry constituted two-thirds of the local economy.
  3. And a half of all of the fires in the county were the result of growing mishaps.
When they showed the nice, Caucasian, salt of the earth family that was forced to move out of their home because of their fear of the marijuana growers, even we at MJO were alarmed. The rest of the documentary proceeded to heighten our fears: there were stories of crime sprees, a desperate woman's 911 call when her son's head was brutally bashed in during a marijuana robbery (not to fear, she shot the bastards), worries about the environmental effects of the industrial pollution produced by growers, and a desperate plea by a former chairman of Mendocino County's Board of Supervisors for federal and state help.

Next, was a story about Bruce Perlowin and his early-80s San Francisco based marijuana smuggling empire. Undoubtedly, an interesting tale that ends with Perlowin leaving his Playbook in a Denny's and being apprehended. However, MJO learned nothing from this segment aside from the dangers of greed and stupidity. And considering that Perlowin got out after nine years in a federal penitentiary with at least some of his millions seemingly intact, the dangers do not seem that great.

Finally, the report presents an immigration problem. The filmmakers exposed several remote outdoor gardens and highlighted the beans, tortillas, and salsa that were left by the criminals at the site. There was some discussion of the superb irrigation systems used by Hispanics along with talk of the growers incredible innate ability to survive on a relative pittance alone in the forest. And finally much of the blame for the entire situation was pinned on Mexican drug cartels.

All of these stories were presented with sound effects and general production values that you would expect from an episode of Extra. The reporter, Trish Regan, while expressing her astonishment with the prevalence of marijuana at every opportunity availed to her, also kept a quizzical, if not confused, look on her face throughout her "investigative journalism." When presented the opportunity to ask the head DEA agent of Northern California why they did not crackdown on the industry, Regan let the agent off the hook with "Well, you cant blame it on us." Armed with the knowledge that an American county's economy is thriving in the marijuana trade, there were no queries about the suitability of this on a national scale. In light of our present economic troubles, this seems to be a particularly egregious error on the part of America's Business Channel.

Ultimately, that is why we cannot call Marijuana, Inc. a documentary. There were simply too many personal stories and not enough facts. While the sensationalistic stories are entertaining, in the end we just didn't learn anything of substance because of their limited scope. Because of this, MJO sees Marijuana, Inc. as a failed opportunity by CNBC to present an informative, objective, and macroscopic glimpse into the underground Marijuana narco-economy.

Did you see Marijuana, Inc.? Let us know what you thought. Leave a comment!
Read More...